Quincus logo

Engineering

Degraded mode is a capacity number, not an incident

PublishedNov 18, 2026Read3 minJournalQuincus core

On November 10, DatamarNews reported that a failure in the information systems of the Santos Port Authority, which began on November 6 after a power fluctuation, had disrupted procedures for vessel, truck and train movements at the Port of Santos, with tasks normally handled by automated systems performed manually, including checks of whether a vessel's dimensions were compatible with an available berth. The authority said operations were continuing with contingency procedures and that delays could occur. On November 11, the same outlet reported the authority's chief executive expected systems to be restored by November 13.

What the week exposed is a number that almost no port, terminal or network can state: its throughput with the system down.

Every automated check has a manual service time

A port's capacity is usually described by its cranes, berths, gate lanes and yard slots. But between the physical assets sits a layer of decisions: is this truck expected, does this ship fit this berth, which block does this box go to, which train slot is open. When the decisions are automated, each one takes seconds and the physical assets set the pace. When the decisions go manual, each one acquires a human service time, and the decision layer becomes the constraint.

Take an illustrative gate. An automated lane processes a truck in about 30 seconds, 120 trucks an hour. A manual check takes about 3 minutes, 20 trucks an hour. A 6-lane gate falls from 720 trucks an hour to 120. A terminal that receives 5,000 trucks a day clears them in about 7 hours at full automation and needs about 42 hours manually. The queue is not a delay. It is the difference between 2 capacities, accumulating every hour the fallback is in force.

The same arithmetic applies at the berth. A compatibility check that a system answers in seconds becomes a planner with a drawing and a tide table. It does not stop the ship, but it moves the berthing decision, and every hour of slack it introduces is an hour of quay the port cannot sell.

Degraded mode is designed, or it is improvised

The capacity of a facility with its systems down is a design parameter. It can be measured before the event and improved by decisions made before the event. In the operations we have seen, few have measured it, because the system has never been down long enough to find out, and because nobody owns the number.

3 choices set it. The first is which decisions are pre-computed. A berth plan for the next 48 hours, a yard allocation for the vessels already on the schedule, a gate appointment list for tomorrow: if these exist outside the live system, in a form a human can read, the fallback starts from a plan rather than from nothing. The second is which decisions truly need the live system. Re-sequencing a crane after a late arrival does. Confirming that a 366-meter ship fits a 400-meter berth does not, and should never have depended on it. The third is what the manual service times are. If no one has timed a manual gate check, the degraded capacity is a guess, and the first real outage is the measurement.

The system is part of the capacity

Planning systems raise throughput. The consequence is that the system becomes part of the installed capacity in exactly the way a crane is. A crane has a maintenance schedule and a plan for the day it is out. The planning layer deserves the same: a stated degraded throughput, a tested fallback, and plans pre-computed far enough ahead to cover a restoration.

A port that can say what it moves per hour with its systems down has designed its degraded mode. A port that cannot will find out the way everyone finds out, 1 hour at a time.

Journal

New essays by email.

One email when a new essay is published. Nothing else.

By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy.

If your network makes decisions under uncertainty, we should talk.

We work with a small number of operators at a time. Tell us what your network is optimizing for.

Start a conversation