Quincus logo

Air cargo

A fuel surcharge prices the wrong scarcity

PublishedNov 16, 2026Read3 minJournalQuincus core

On November 12, Air Cargo News reported TAC Index data showing the Baltic Air Freight Index up 6.6 percent in the week to November 9 and 28.2 percent above a year earlier, the highest level of 2026 and above the previous 2 peak season highs. The same report cited the IATA jet fuel price monitor: average fuel prices in the week ending November 6 were down 6.5 percent on the prior week and 7 percent on a month earlier.

Fuel down, rates up. That combination is not a paradox. It is a reminder that the air cargo tariff is still built as if cost set the price, in a market where scarcity sets it.

What the surcharge says and what the market did

Most air cargo rates are quoted as a base rate plus a fuel surcharge indexed to a published fuel price. Take an illustrative all-in rate of 3.50 dollars per kilogram, split into a 2.50 base and a 1.00 fuel surcharge that tracks the index without lag. A 6.5 percent fall in the index removes about 6.5 cents from the surcharge. A 6.6 percent rise in the all-in rate adds about 23 cents. For both to be true, the base rate had to rise by about 30 cents, or 12 percent, in a single week.

So the instrument that is supposed to explain price movement to the customer explained a 7 cent decrease while the price rose 23 cents. The customer who tracks the fuel index was told to expect relief and received an increase. The surcharge is indexed to a real cost, but in peak season the thing that moves the price is not a cost. It is the shadow price of a position on a full aircraft.

Price is cost plus a scarcity rent, and the rent is the variable

The economics are plain. Below full load, the marginal cost of carrying 1 more kilogram is close to fuel and handling, and a cost-indexed price is honest. At full load, the marginal cost of carrying 1 more kilogram is the revenue of the kilogram it displaces. That displacement value depends on the probability the flight departs full and on what the displaced shipper would have paid. Neither number appears in a fuel index.

In the operations we have seen, the scarcity rent in a tight week can exceed the entire fuel surcharge. When that happens the surcharge is not wrong, it is irrelevant: it describes a fraction of the price and is used to explain all of it.

Index the thing that actually moves

The practical change is to separate what is passed through from what is priced. Fuel is a pass-through: it is a cost, it is observable, and it should move with its index, up and down, without argument. Space is priced: its value is a forecast of load factor by flight and by day, and it should be quoted as its own component with its own logic.

A quote structured that way does 3 things. It stops the customer conversation from being about fuel in a week when fuel is falling. It gives the pricing desk a number to forecast, the probability that a given departure is full, rather than a number to look up. And it makes the margin visible: a week in which fuel falls 6.5 percent and the all-in rises 6.6 percent is a week in which the space component rose by far more than the headline, and the desk should know by how much.

Rates reached a 2026 high while the cost of flying fell. The market priced the position, not the fuel. A tariff that names fuel as the moving part is reporting the wrong variable, and a desk that forecasts the fuel index to predict next week's rate is forecasting the wrong one too.

Journal

New essays by email.

One email when a new essay is published. Nothing else.

By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy.

If your network makes decisions under uncertainty, we should talk.

We work with a small number of operators at a time. Tell us what your network is optimizing for.

Start a conversation